The analogy. The box of library and the box of the Faraday's Chair by Dunne & Raby. Library as one way data transferring hut.The traditional library, with its voluminous space, are seen merely as a structural shed, protecting those trillions of data. The space for human activities are voids cut out from this block of data, where data seekers wander around the surfaces of the void. The linear and univalent classification of data often misguide and disappoint passionate data seekers when the mass of data itself could easily overwhelm one's sense of orientation.

The tedious search and the linear presentation of data make the traditional library not more than acting as a decorated shed, often with facade clad with ornamental classical stone, high columns, capitals, wide pediment, and red dressed Queen's guards posted on the two flanks of the monumental doorway. In the east, often in the form of a pretentious buffalo roof, with false concrete rabbets and a bunch of moody pensioner-wannabe civil servant, waiting to annoy anytime you try to cause him leaving his chair. It is certainly not a place for social chemistry nor a shared public realm.
The huge amount of data, generated and overlapped over the human history are uncanny. Both wanted and unwanted, both valuable and discardable for the current human progress and civilization, are store in this warehouse. Thus, the library is the dumping site of expired data. A multi-layered bedrock of intellectual junk, slowly dying in its role in our 21th century world of zero-waste cabled information megastore.
Hmm, I think the concept of library in the Malaysian context is very different from the west. The historic rise of the public sector in the West in tandem with the 20th century global economic crisis resulted in a sort of 'revolution' in the growth of government-initiated cultural institutions such as public libraries & museums. Western libraries are no longer constricted to professional & academic pursuits. Rather, libraries have become a cultural & social collective public realm where even mothers regularly come over with their children to periodically borrow resources, the juveniles for extra-curricular activities, job seekers for opportunities, & the veterans for lifelong learning programmes.
ReplyDeleteIn contrast, development in Malaysia is still dominated by the private sector, such that even social tasks of urban regeneration are handed over by the council to private developers. As Koolhaas said, the programme defined by profit-based developers are rarely multi-faceted & socially as beneficial, yet these are what have been & currently being the main constituents of our alleged 'development'. The less profitable public institutions, on the other hand, are literally left to rot. The programme of a Malaysian library is still very much like the obsolete age-old traditional western library of simple 'data storage decorated shed', despite our alleged 'revolution' in Information Technology. To complement this, it even have an age-old traditional form & workforce....
One of the things that perplexed me the most is that Malaysians are willing to pay to spend hours in cyber cafes, yet, unlike the West, no initiative has been taken to integrate the role of these places into a more socially cohesive community library. You could do similar things in a library with less cost. Why is our allegedly money-based society choosing the over-priced cybercafes instead?
One of the main 'rationale' of Malaysian development is to submit to popular interest & culture. "Malaysians don't read, so we don't need libraries". In the west, libraries are an agent to promote the reading culture, not simply as a product to cater for a 'sudden' rise in reading habits.
In contrast to the Western professional culture, ours do not seem to have much of a drive to change or even question popular 'trends'. We have simply become slaves to the market whims & fancies. We have no responsibility to convince them of what we professionally think is best. We have not enough credibility for our professional opinions to be recognized, beyond the issues of form. indeed, we have simply become exterior decorators....
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDelete